Sweetheart deal on WIS

Posted March 30, 2008 by colafacts
Categories: City Council

FULL TEXT OF CAMERON’S SPEECH:

Cameron Runyan Remarks – 03/28/08 Press Conference

Thank you…everyone…for coming today. As was reported this morning in The State newspaper, there are numerous issues with the Five Points High Rise Project that have been well documented ranging from the City of Columbia providing $5.8 million for a sweetheart land deal to now very serious environmental concerns.

Therefore, initially today I want to document to the public, to the press… and hopefully to City Council how real these concerns really are… so here are documents from DHEC, environmental experts and, believe it or not, even our City of Columbia government that prove that there is hazardous waste on this site and these concerns alone are enough to warrant more due diligence on the project and this site will have to be cleaned up before any re-development can occur.

But unfortunately, I am afraid…I am here today to report that the specter of financial improprieties may also plague this project.

What has yet to be reported and was brought to my attention late yesterday afternoon is that before, during, and after the initial votes on this project, Councilman Daniel Rickenmann has had a direct financial relationship with the original owner of the Kenny’s Auto property and Mr. Rickenmann may have potentially violated state law.

The facts are:

Within roughly two months of the original owner selling his property across the street to developers who received our tax dollars…The original owner purchased a building owned by Mr. Rickenmann for what appears to be a significant profit.

Now I would like to provide you with three documents. First, the county’s two transaction statements detailing the sale of the Kenny’s property and Mr. Rickenmann’s building sale.

And finally I want to provide you with a copy of a section of our State Ethics law. Statute 8-13-725 states that…and I quote “a public official may not make, participate in making, or in any way attempt to use his office to influence a governmental decision in which he, a member of his immediate family, an individual with whom he is associated or a business with which he is associated has an economic interest.”

Now I cannot and should not be judge and jury on Mr. Rickenmann’s violation of this law. That should be looked at by the appropriate authorities. I can say that this statute gives me a great concern that Mr. Rickenmann may have violated some state laws.

But at a minimum, this doesn’t pass the smell test. Mr. Rickenmann should have at least abstained from voting to prevent the appearance of any impropriety.

Therefore, I would like to call on Mr. Rickenmann and City Council to do the following:

First, the City’s legal council should work with the State Ethics Commission, the County Solicitor and any other appropriate legal authorities to determine if any laws were violated.

Second, in the interest of public disclosure Mr. Rickenmann and the other parties should completely disclose all of the documents regarding the sale and purchase of the kenny’s property and Mr. Rickenmann’s building. Sun light is the best disinfectant…so this would go along way to clear the air.

Third, Mr. Rickenmann should no longer vote on any question before council related to this property.

This is clearly a bad deal for the City. Too many ethical and policy questions now exist. I hope that my efforts on the issue over the last few weeks will be impetus enough to give the rest of the council pause before proceeding.

Thank you and I would be glad to take any questions.

Five Points Parking Garage: The Full Story

Posted March 30, 2008 by colafacts
Categories: Uncategorized

Part I – THE SWEETHEART DEAL

How would you like to receive a $5.8 million sweetheart deal from the City of Columbia for your next project? That’s exactly the gift the City of Columbia and its City Council voted 6-0 to give last year to HR Developers, LLC for a building project in Five Points (Kirkman Finlay was recused). [VIEW DOCUMENT]

In fact, City Council promised the money more than five weeks before the developers, Washington Square, LLC, closed on the property. [VIEW DOCUMENT]

Worse yet, the City considered this deal behind closed doors in executive session and voted to approve it without public discussion. [Feb 21 Minutes] [Minutes March 7]

Washington Square, LLC, the developer that bought the land, and HR Developers, LLC, the developer of the Five Points South project on that land, are owned by the same two individual developers.

These same developers have had a profitable real estate dealing with the City before. [VIEW DOCUMENT] And contributed to Councilman Daniel Rickenmann’s campaign a few years afterward in July of 2005.

Did City Staff believe this behind-closed-doors transaction was a “done deal”?

1. Yes, according to Chip Land, the head of City Planning when speaking to the Planning Commissioners about the sweetheart deal. In the Commission’s formal hearing for a zoning exemption to allow construction of a mixed-use massive six-story building, Mr. Land stated “City Council has already voted to go into contract with the developers to acquire the air rights and to build two levels of parking.” [See Transcript of Minutes, September 10, 2007] The exemption from zoning for the deal was approved by the Planning Commission. (One of these two developers has been a Past Chairman of the Columbia Planning Commission.)

2. According to the Assistant City Manager, no other options for a parking garage were to be examined, and he was directed not to look at other options within Five Points.

Part II – RICKENMANN’S DEAL

Has Councilman Rickenmann made a ton of money connected to the sweetheart deal?

It certainly appears so. His partnership received a $500,000 profit from the purchase of the Birds on a Wire building 15 days before the vote on the sweetheart deal and the sale to Kenny Hooks (former owner of Kenny’s) 5 months later.

What are the facts?

 

  1. Councilman Rickenmann’s partnership (Foodworks Creative Development Company) bought the building at 2901 Devine Street for $1.45m only 15 days before the vote to commit $5.8m of public funds to a private developer for a project on Kenny’s Auto Site.
  2. Councilman Rickenmann held onto the property for 5 months, during which time the private developer bought the land at Kenny’s Auto (700 and 701 Saluda Avenue) for “a record price for Five Points” according to newspaper accounts.
  3. Less than three months after the Kenny’s property was sold by Mr. Hooks, Mr. Rickenmann sold his building at 2901 Devine Street to Mr. Hooks for $1.95m.

Check it out for yourself online at the assessor’s office:

http://www.richlandonline.com/services/assessorsearch/assessorsearch.asp

What really happened?

Did the private developer increase the price he paid for the Kenny’s Auto by $500,000 so that money could be flowed through to Mr. Rickenmann on the next transaction? Did the vote increase the property value of Kenny’s Auto and Mr. Rickenmann receive the benefit? Was it an innocent coincidence? We won’t know what really happened until this is investigated.

The citizens of Columbia deserve to know whether this deal violates laws preventing public officials from making decisions that benefit them personally.

Part III – THE POLLUTED DEAL

Does the former Kenny’s site have environmental problems?

Yes, the site has major environmental contamination, including 4000% of acceptable level of benzene in the groundwater on the site. Benzene is an additive in gasoline that can cause cancer. The site has other contaminants, including heating oil/diesel and used oil. It is heavily polluted. [VIEW DOCUMENTS]

View Environmental Site Map

 

How long has the information been available to the City? Since at least August 2006, when the documents were filed with DHEC. The information that the site was polluted was available before City Council ever voted to give the developers the sweetheart deal in March 2007. [View DHEC Letter]

Just last month, the polluted site was judged by City Staff as superior in physical suitability compared to a clean site. There was no mention of the environmental problems.

The environmental information was available when City Council recently chose this site over another clean site in its March 5, 2008 meeting.

But don’t just listen to us. Citizens have raised this environmental issue but it’s fallen on deaf ears. Check out a guest editorial by a member of the public published in the State newspaper last week. [http://www.thestate.com/editorial-columns/story/349399.html]

 

 

Dear Friend:

The City should never have voted for the sweetheart deal and it should not be considering signing more contracts right now.

The process has been dirty and the site is polluted. Appropriate public private development is essential to growth, however, this is a backroom deal, it’s negligent, and a member of City Council has compared it to the hotel deal.

Don’t just ask me. Ask the taxpayers….at least 50 Five Points merchants and over 500 citizens are adamantly opposed to this deal and have been trying to have their voices heard without success.

That’s why I’m running…to represent the taxpayers. If you have any questions or ideas, please call my cell at 422-4895. We need someone to bring about Accountable Change and I would be honored to have your support.

Cameron Runyan

In The News:

WIS TV:
Friday, March 28: WIS TV Reports: Candidate Calls on The Smell Test
Sunday, March 30: WIS TV Newswatch: Debate

The State:
Saturday, March 29: Five Points Deal Questioned
Friday, March 28: Rivals Clash Over Five Points Plan

Cameron Runyan’s 3 Point Open Government Plan

Posted March 11, 2008 by colafacts
Categories: City Council

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Wednesday, March 19, 2008

CONTACT: Cameron Runyan, 803-422-4895

NEWS RELEASE

Runyan Calls for Accountable Change
Council Candidate Wants Openness, Citizen Involvement in City Government

Columbia, SC – Columbia City Council (At-Large) Candidate Cameron Runyan continued his campaign for accountable change this morning by calling for more openness in city government.

 

In the spirit of March Madness, Runyan announced his three-point plan to add accountability, openness, and citizen involvement in Columbia’s city government.

Runyan stated, “I’m running for City Council to bring a voice to Columbia’s citizens. Currently, the good ol’ boy closed door system at City Hall enables the status quo to remain stagnant. I’ve learned that sunshine is the best disinfectant for government. Frankly, it’s time to open the curtains at City Hall and let the sun shine through and onto our city’s government.”

Runyan continued, “All across the city, people are filling out their brackets in the spirit of March Madness. All I ask is that when they view the April 1st City Council bracket, they take a hard look at my campaign for accountable change. Today, I announced my Three Point Plan for Openness and I am ready to get to work to score a victory for Columbia’s citizens and taxpayers.”

Runyan’s Three Point Plan for Openness includes:

48 HOUR RULE:

Stagnant Status Quo: Council provides favors to friends with little accountability by acting on action items not found on a meeting’s agenda until just minutes before council meetings.

Runyan’s Reform: Council Agenda must be published, made public and firmly set at least 48 hours before all Council Meetings, with a provision made for exceptions in emergency situations.


21st CENTURY COMMUNICATIONS:

Stagnant Status Quo: Channel 2 loops meetings without an announced schedule and there is no searchable archive of video. While minutes are supposed to be uploaded, the most current minutes date back to 2007. Citizens must fill out forms and wait days to view legislation their city government passed.

Runyan’s Reform: Place all council minutes, agendas, and ordinances in a searchable database online in addition to live streaming of Channel 2 and a video archive of council meetings. Minutes, Agendas, and Ordinances should be uploaded within 24 hours of their announcement.

OPEN DOORS:

Stagnant Status Quo: City Council meets in the morning when it is difficult for citizens with jobs to attend.

Runyan’s Reform: Move Council meetings to the evenings when citizens are better able to attend council meetings and take a more active role in their city’s government

 

# # #

Paid for by the Community to Elect Cameron Runyan

Welcome

Posted March 9, 2008 by colafacts
Categories: About

Welcome to Cola Facts, a new site created to open the doors of city government to the people of our great city.

This is site is a product of Cameron Runyan’s campaign for City Council.

Cameron Runyan is running for City Council to bring about Accountable Change for the city. Core tenants of his platform include opening up city government in order to allow the sun to shine through and bring forth a more accountable, effective, and efficient government in order to properly serve the citizens of Columbia.